| 1 | Rd 1 | Ronald | Acuna | OF | ATL | evil 1 |
| 2 | Mike | Trout | OF | LAA | Koufax | |
| 3 | Fernando | Tatis | SS | SD | Cultus | |
| 4 | Juan | Soto | OF | WSH | snarfman | |
| 5 | Mookie | Betts | OF | LAD | EdgeO | |
| 6 | Shane | Bieber | SP | CLE | Spacey Spacers | |
| 7 | Trea | Turner | SS | WSH | Sander | |
| 8 | Jacob | deGrom | SP | NYM | drafter01 | |
| 9 | Freddie | Freeman | 1B | ATL | Beer League | |
| 10 | Gerrit | Cole | SP | NYY | RandLTex | |
| 11 | Rd 2 | Trevor | Story | SS | COL | RandLTex |
| 12 | Jose | Ramirez | 3B | CLE | Beer League | |
| 13 | Christian | Yelich | OF | MIL | drafter01 | |
| 14 | Cody | Bellinger | OF | LAD | Sander | |
| 15 | Francisco | Lindor | SS | CLE | Spacey Spacers | |
| 16 | Luis | Castillo | SP | CIN | EdgeO | |
| 17 | Jose | Abreu | 1B | CHW | snarfman | |
| 18 | Marcell | Ozuna | OF | FA | Cultus | |
| 19 | Walker | Buehler | SP | LAD | Koufax | |
| 20 | Bryce | Harper | OF | PHI | evil 1 | |
| 21 | Rd 3 | Nolan | Arenado | 3B | COL | evil 1 |
| 22 | Yu | Darvish | SP | CHC | Koufax | |
| 23 | Trevor | Bauer | SP | FA | Cultus | |
| 24 | Manny | Machado | 3B | SD | snarfman | |
| 25 | Eloy | Jimenez | OF | CHW | EdgeO | |
| 26 | Lucas | Giolito | SP | CHW | Spacey Spacers | |
| 27 | Ozzie | Albies | 2B | ATL | Sander | |
| 28 | Aaron | Nola | SP | PHI | drafter01 | |
| 29 | DJ | LeMahieu | 2B | FA | Beer League | |
| 30 | Luke | Voit | 1B | NYY | RandLTex | |
| 31 | Rd 4 | Brandon | Woodruff | SP | MIL | RandLTex |
| 32 | Clayton | Kershaw | SP | LAD | Beer League | |
| 33 | Pete | Alonso | 1B | NYM | drafter01 | |
| 34 | Jack | Flaherty | SP | STL | Sander | |
| 35 | George | Springer | OF | FA | Spacey Spacers | |
| 36 | Anthony | Rendon | 3B | LAA | EdgeO | |
| 37 | Corey | Seager | SS | LAD | snarfman | |
| 38 | Rafael | Devers | 3B | BOS | Cultus | |
| 39 | Max | Scherzer | SP | WSH | Koufax | |
| 40 | Alex | Bregman | 3B | HOU | evil 1 | |
| 41 | Rd 5 | Aaron | Judge | OF | NYY | evil 1 |
| 42 | Randy | Arozarena | OF | TB | Koufax | |
| 43 | Charlie | Blackmon | OF | COL | Cultus | |
| 44 | Xander | Bogaerts | SS | BOS | snarfman | |
| 45 | Bo | Bichette | SS | TOR | EdgeO | |
| 46 | Kyle | Tucker | OF | HOU | Spacey Spacers | |
| 47 | Zac | Gallen | SP | AZ | Sander | |
| 48 | Adalberto | Mondesi | SS | KC | drafter01 | |
| 49 | Luis | Robert | OF | CHW | Beer League | |
| 50 | Whit | Merrifield | OF | KC | RandLTex | |
| 51 | Rd 6 | Tim | Anderson | SS | CHW | RandLTex |
| 52 | Blake | Snell | SP | TB | Beer League | |
| 53 | J.T. | Realmuto | C | FA | drafter01 | |
| 54 | Starling | Marte | OF | MIA | Sander | |
| 55 | Teoscar | Hernandez | OF | TOR | Spacey Spacers | |
| 56 | Sonny | Gray | SP | CIN | EdgeO | |
| 57 | Max | Fried | SP | ATL | snarfman | |
| 58 | Kenta | Maeda | SP | MIN | Cultus | |
| 59 | Giancarlo | Stanton | OF | NYY | Koufax | |
| 60 | Tyler | Glasnow | SP | TB | evil 1 | |
| 61 | Rd 7 | Eugenio | Suarez | 3B | CIN | evil 1 |
| 62 | Kyle | Lewis | OF | SEA | Koufax | |
| 63 | Ketel | Marte | 2B | AZ | Cultus | |
| 64 | Vladimir | Guerrero Jr. | 1B | TOR | snarfman | |
| 65 | Zach | Plesac | SP | CLE | EdgeO | |
| 66 | Paul | Goldschmidt | 1B | STL | Spacey Spacers | |
| 67 | Josh | Hader | RP | MIL | Sander | |
| 68 | J.D. | Martinez | DH | BOS | drafter01 | |
| 69 | Lourdes | Gurriel | OF | TOR | Beer League | |
| 70 | Yordan | Alvarez | DH | HOU | RandLTex | |
| 71 | Rd 8 | Nelson | Cruz | DH | FA | RandLTex |
| 72 | Keston | Hiura | 2B | MIL | Beer League | |
| 73 | Cavan | Biggio | 2B | TOR | drafter01 | |
| 74 | Dominic | Smith | 1B | NYM | Sander | |
| 75 | Aroldis | Chapman | RP | NYY | Spacey Spacers | |
| 76 | Matt | Olson | 1B | OAK | EdgeO | |
| 77 | Dinelson | Lamet | SP | SD | snarfman | |
| 78 | Hyun-Jin | Ryu | SP | TOR | Cultus | |
| 79 | Mike | Moustakas | 2B | CIN | Koufax | |
| 80 | Jose | Altuve | 2B | HOU | evil 1 | |
| 81 | Rd 9 | Liam | Hendriks | RP | FA | evil 1 |
| 82 | Max | Muncy | 1B | LAD | Koufax | |
| 83 | Brandon | Lowe | 2B | TB | Cultus | |
| 84 | Will | Smith | C | LAD | snarfman | |
| 85 | Corbin | Burnes | SP | MIL | EdgeO | |
| 86 | Lance | Lynn | SP | TEX | Spacey Spacers | |
| 87 | Michael | Conforto | OF | NYM | Sander | |
| 88 | Jonathan | Villar | 2B | FA | drafter01 | |
| 89 | Wil | Myers | OF | SD | Beer League | |
| 90 | Salvador | Perez | C | KC | RandLTex | |
| 91 | Rd 10 | Zack | Greinke | SP | HOU | RandLTex |
| 92 | Ian | Anderson | SP | ATL | Beer League | |
| 93 | Austin | Meadows | OF | TB | drafter01 | |
| 94 | Yoan | Moncada | 3B | CHW | Sander | |
| 95 | Anthony | Rizzo | 1B | CHC | Spacey Spacers | |
| 96 | Carlos | Carrasco | SP | CLE | EdgeO | |
| 97 | Nick | Castellanos | OF | CIN | snarfman | |
| 98 | Mike | Yastrzemski | OF | SF | Cultus | |
| 99 | Yasmani | Grandal | C | CHW | Koufax | |
| 100 | Mike | Soroka | SP | ATL | evil11 | |
| 101 | Rd 11 | Carlos | Correa | SS | HOU | evil11 |
| 102 | Chris | Paddack | SP | SD | Koufax | |
| 103 | Brad | Hand | RP | FA | Cultus | |
| 104 | Stephen | Strasburg | SP | WSH | snarfman | |
| 105 | Max | Kepler | OF | MIN | EdgeO | |
| 106 | Matt | Chapman | 3B | OAK | Spacey Spacers | |
| 107 | Alec | Bohm | 3B | PHI | Sander | |
| 108 | Javier | Baez | SS | CHC | drafter01 | |
| 109 | Dansby | Swanson | SS | ATL | Beer League | |
| 110 | Jose | Berrios | SP | MIN | RandLTex | |
| 111 | Rd 12 | Trent | Grisham | OF | SD | RandLTex |
| 112 | James | Karinchak | RP | CLE | Beer League | |
| 113 | Eddie | Rosario | OF | FA | drafter01 | |
| 114 | Marcus | Semien | SS | FA | Sander | |
| 115 | Jake | Cronenworth | 2B | SD | Spacey Spacers | |
| 116 | Gleyber | Torres | SS | NYY | EdgeO | |
| 117 | Zack | Wheeler | SP | PHI | snarfman | |
| 118 | Willson | Contreras | C | CHC | Cultus | |
| 119 | Josh | Bell | 1B | PIT | Koufax | |
| 120 | Tommy | Pham | OF | SD | evil11 | |
| 121 | Rd 13 | Rhys | Hoskins | 1B | PHI | evil11 |
| 122 | Charlie | Morton | SP | ATL | Koufax | |
| 123 | Kyle | Hendricks | SP | CHC | Cultus | |
| 124 | Brian | Anderson | 3B | MIA | snarfman | |
| 125 | Michael | Brantley | OF | FA | EdgeO | |
| 126 | Raisel | Iglesias | RP | CIN | Spacey Spacers | |
| 127 | Lance | McCullers | SP | HOU | Sander | |
| 128 | Will | Smith | RP | ATL | drafter01 | |
| 129 | Travis | d'Arnaud | C | ATL | Beer League | |
| 130 | Gio | Urshela | 3B | NYY | RandLTex | |
| 131 | Rd 14 | Franmil | Reyes | OF | CLE | RandLTex |
| 132 | Nick | Anderson | RP | TB | Beer League | |
| 133 | Taylor | Rogers | RP | MIN | drafter01 | |
| 134 | Byron | Buxton | OF | MIN | Sander | |
| 135 | Kenley | Jansen | RP | LAD | Spacey Spacers | |
| 136 | Jeff | McNeil | OF | NYM | EdgeO | |
| 137 | Alex | Colome | RP | FA | snarfman | |
| 138 | Alex | Verdugo | OF | BOS | Cultus | |
| 139 | Julio | Urias | SP | LAD | Koufax | |
| 140 | Sixto | Sanchez | SP | MIA | evil11 | |
| 141 | Rd 15 | Jesus | Luzardo | SP | OAK | evil11 |
| 142 | Gavin | Lux | 2B | LAD | Koufax | |
| 143 | Joey | Gallo | OF | TEX | Cultus | |
| 144 | Ke'Bryan | Hayes | 3B | PIT | snarfman | |
| 145 | Jared | Walsh | 1B | LAA | EdgeO | |
| 146 | Didi | Gregorius | SS | FA | Spacey Spacers | |
| 147 | Pablo | Lopez | SP | MIA | Sander | |
| 148 | Kris | Bryant | 3B | CHC | drafter01 | |
| 149 | Josh | Donaldson | 3B | MIN | Beer League | |
| 150 | Dylan | Moore | OF | SEA | RandLTex | |
| 151 | Rd 16 | Justin | Turner | 3B | FA | RandLTex |
| 152 | Dylan | Bundy | SP | LAA | Beer League | |
| 153 | Marco | Gonzales | SP | SEA | drafter01 | |
| 154 | David | Price | SP | LAD | Sander | |
| 155 | James | McCann | C | FA | Spacey Spacers | |
| 156 | Ryan | Pressly | RP | HOU | EdgeO | |
| 157 | Jesse | Winker | OF | CIN | snarfman | |
| 158 | Jose | Urquidy | SP | HOU | Cultus | |
| 159 | Wander | Franco | SS | TB | Koufax | |
| 160 | Patrick | Corbin | SP | WSH | evil11 | |
| 161 | Rd 17 | Gary | Sanchez | C | NYY | evil11 |
| 162 | Dustin | May | SP | LAD | Koufax | |
| 163 | Christian | Walker | 1B | AZ | Cultus | |
| 164 | Chris | Taylor | OF | LAD | snarfman | |
| 165 | Tommy | Edman | 3B | STL | EdgeO | |
| 166 | Victor | Robles | OF | WSH | Spacey Spacers | |
| 167 | Sean | Murphy | C | OAK | Sander | |
| 168 | Framber | Valdez | SP | HOU | drafter01 | |
| 169 | Jorge | Soler | DH | KC | Beer League | |
| 170 | Edwin | Diaz | RP | NYM | RandLTex | |
| 171 | Rd 18 | Ryan | McMahon | 2B | COL | RandLTex |
| 172 | Miguel | Sano | 1B | MIN | Beer League | |
| 173 | Eric | Hosmer | 1B | SD | drafter01 | |
| 174 | Ian | Happ | OF | CHC | Sander | |
| 175 | Ramon | Laureano | OF | OAK | Spacey Spacers | |
| 176 | Christian | Vazquez | C | BOS | EdgeO | |
| 177 | Devin | Williams | RP | MIL | snarfman | |
| 178 | Jesus | Aguilar | 1B | MIA | Cultus | |
| 179 | Joey | Votto | 1B | CIN | Koufax | |
| 180 | Eduardo | Escobar | 3B | AZ | evil11 |